deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

October 9, 2009
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 67
Favourites: 0
Views: 160 (0 today)
[x]

War on Halloween?

Fri Oct 9, 2009, 2:26 PM


(title is a joke, but really.)

[link]

Seriously?

When I was a kid, I remember the year that we had to have a chaperone while trick-or-treating for the first time. It was kind of a drag. We, as children, wanted to run screaming like wild banshees all over the place; that's sort of the whole idea. But we still managed to have fun with an adult present. After all, one or two adults, thirty or forty kids...we were still in charge!

If we had been given a 4-hour party at the fire hall instead, it would have taken away the entire point of Halloween - namely, participating in some tame chaos, scaring our neighbors, yelling until we were hoarse, TPing lawns, fighting for the most candy and getting to let out a lot of pent-up energy. You can have a party anytime. A party isn't a challenge; it doesn't offer a lot of exercise (and it was a workout to run around for 3 hours looking for houses that still had candy - I grew up in a rural area), and how many of those cranky old neighbors do you think would show up? About zero.

The adults in the article really miss the point of Halloween. It's not about the candy, it's about getting a tiny little taste of freedom and control over your own life. For a few hours a year, you're not on a short leash. You get to run and scream and cause mayhem. I enjoyed Halloween more than Christmas and Easter.

And in my entire childhood, not one single child was hurt on Halloween. No one got lost or murdered or kidnapped, and no one got fed a razor apple or cyanide candy. (I grew up in a small town like the one in the article, for the record. I don't know what it's like trick-or-treating in the city.)

I know the difference between anecdotal and statistical data, of course, so I have to wonder - do the statistics really say that children are at any significant risk if they trick-or-treat with an adult chaperone? Was there some sort of event that caused this, or is it just people getting hysterical again?

  • Mood: Sadness
Add a Comment:
 
:iconbrokenever:
I didn't get to go trick or treating without a parent until middle school, but banning it altogether? Not right at all.
Reply
:iconzaphy1415926:
I understand the paranoia surrounding Halloween and nutjobs poisoning candy and such, after all, that's kind of a parent's job, to worry about their kids. However, 1) deciding what their kids are and are not going to do should be the responsibility of the parents, not the town. That's why children don't get thrown in jail every time they hit their siblings or something- until children come of age it is the responsibility of the parents to discipline and protect their children. 2) I'd think they could come up with a better compromise than that. Mandating that a chaperon should be with all groups of children at all times would at least allow the children a little freedom.

At least they didn't ban the holiday outright though, right? XP
Reply
:iconfractal-inversion:
I love Halloween and I'm not even American... the little celebrations we do have in Australia are awesome, so I feel for you losing part of that bigger awesome :)
I read about the whole razorblade candy thing on Snopes once though... apparently it's mostly an urban myth, as the few people crazy enough to do something like that were doing to their own children :(
Reply
:iconmaruhatesgravity:
It's just another brand of the hysteria that the media likes to perpetuate, and if that makes me sound like some kind of conspiracy theorist I'll readily accept that label. :XD:

Really, banning trick-or-treating? That's like banning the Thanksgiving turkey, Christmas presents, Easter egg hunts, fireworks...

The fact that this pea-brained minion of the fearmongers is "surprised" that people are reacting negatively to banning a fun tradition just makes me cringe. And the fact that this seems to be over break-ins only further proves that the "officials" in question are idiots; criminals will continue being criminals whether or not trick-or-treating is banned.

It's one of those incidents that would make an awesome South Park episode, but in real life, it just makes you want to bang your head against a wall. =P
Reply
:icon113innerdemons:
~113innerdemons Oct 11, 2009  Professional General Artist
me and my buddies are sitting here and we say: it's people getting hysterical -- yet again... stoopid heads
Reply
:iconbobthedancingflea:
This...is the most ridiculous thing I think I've ever read. Even more ridiculous than the news report about the Asian man getting his penis stuck in a bench. I mean, seriously, is poisoned candy really SO prevalent that we need to ban all trick-or-treating everywhere? Is having your mommy/daddy go trick-or-treating with you actually not enough? And it's not even the fact that they're banning trick-or-treating, but the fact that they seem to be SURPRISED that the kids don't like it. My mind has been boggled. For real.
Reply
:iconnethingbutordinary:
~nethingbutordinary Oct 10, 2009   General Artist
...I've gone trick or treating for as long as I can remember and I live in a city in cali.

I remember my mom would NOT Let us(my sister and I) touch our candy until she and my dad sifted through it throwing away the opened candy and the sketchy stuff.

Only when I was in like, 9th grade and on did I not have a parent with me...I'd be in a BIG group of friends. We were respectful. We just wanted the candy, to stay up late, and hang out! I think parents think their kids are going to do what they did when they were young...but kids are supposed to do stupid things and get in trouble, they can't exactly get away with it when they're adults!

I agree, parties are either before Halloween, or on Halloween night when you're an adult with no kids and want to go have fun. I mean, it's on a SATURDAY night this year! Those poor, poor kids.

This is ridiculous the whole notion of "putting my kid in a bubble is going to protect them" is retarded. I really hate how over-protective the kids are these days. How do they expect them to grow up if you keep setting these restrictions?
Reply
:iconjess4564:
~Jess4564 Oct 10, 2009  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Good Gracious, who would take that away...:?... paranoid parent watchers :shakefish:. Taking away the only way kids have fun dressing up and getting candy for free is a crime...
Reply
:iconletsalldropdead:
~letsalldropdead Oct 10, 2009   Filmographer
man, that's such a dick law. If parents don't want their kids trick-or-treating, it's their responsibility. Not the town's.

If break-ins are the issue, the town should issue pamphlets on public safety or something. PAMPHLETS ARE THE ANSWERRR

Maybe it's just the sensation of getting old and jaded, but since I was a kid I've noticed that each year, halloween gets less celebrated. And that kind of bums me out, cause it's the best holiday, ever.

I remember the fears of razorblades, poison, child abduction, blah blah blah all that stuff And yeah, protecting your kids is important. but to ban a holiday? that's protection to the point of insanity. That's putting kids in a bubble.
Reply
:iconambrmerlinus:

The adults in the article really miss the point of Halloween. It's not about the candy, it's about getting a tiny little taste of freedom and control over your own life. For a few hours a year, you're not on a short leash. You get to run and scream and cause mayhem. I enjoyed Halloween more than Christmas and Easter.


THIS. THIS SO HARD.
Reply
Add a Comment: